GC-MS Analysis of Phthalates: Comparison of GC Stationary Phase Performance

Importance of the Topic

Phthalates serve as plasticizers in numerous consumer and industrial products and are recognized as endocrine disruptors that pose health concerns from birth defects to metabolic disorders. Accurate analysis and separation of phthalates are critical for environmental monitoring, regulatory compliance, and public health protection.

Objectives and Study Overview

This study employed Pro EZGC gas chromatographic modeling software to evaluate the performance of seven Restek GC stationary phases for phthalate analysis. Key goals included optimizing rapid methods for 18 EPA/EU regulated phthalates and an extended set of 37 phthalates, and directly comparing column selectivity and resolution under unified conditions.

Methodology and Experimental Design

• Modeling software Pro EZGC was used to predict retention times and optimize GC parameters including carrier gas flow, temperature program, and column dimensions.
• Seven stationary phases tested: Rtx-440, Rxi-XLB, Rxi-5ms, Rtx-50, Rxi-35Sil MS, Rtx-CLPesticides, and Rtx-CLPesticides2.
• Two temperature programs were defined: a 6-minute run for regulated phthalates and a 40-minute method for the extended list.
• Sample preparation involved dissolution in methylene chloride with benzyl benzoate as internal standard; glassware was used to prevent contamination.

Instrumentation Used

• Shimadzu QP2010 Plus GC-MS operated in full scan mode m/z 59–400, equipped with the seven Restek columns 30 m × 0.25 mm, film thickness 0.25 µm or 0.20 µm.
• Carrier gas He at constant linear velocity; split injection 20  : 1; oven temperature programs as defined in the study; PFTBA tune, electron ionization at 280 °C source temperature.

Main Results and Discussion

• All 18 regulated phthalates were separated in under 6 minutes with baseline resolution achieved on Rtx-440, Rxi-XLB, Rtx-CLPesticides, and Rxi-35Sil MS phases.
• The Rtx-440 and Rxi-XLB columns provided the best overall selectivity, resolving coeluting pairs observed on other phases and separating 34 of 40 peaks in the extended list in under 40 minutes.
• Elution order variations on Rxi-35Sil MS and Rtx-50 highlight the impact of stationary phase chemistry on phthalate interactions.
• Technical grade isomer mixtures remain challenging but can be distinguished by unique extracted ions e.g. m/z 293, 307.

Benefits and Practical Applications

• Rapid method development using modeling software reduces laboratory optimization time.
• High-resolution separation supports regulatory compliance for phthalate monitoring in environmental and consumer samples.
• Recommended column pairs enable direct transfer to GC-ECD methods for confirmatory analysis.

Future Trends and Potential Applications

• Expansion of modeling libraries to include emerging phthalate analogs and isomers.
• Integration of automated method translation to other detectors and platforms.
• Application of high-temperature stable phases for complex matrices and trace-level analysis.

Conclusion

The Pro EZGC software proved effective for rapid optimization of GC-MS methods, with Rtx-440 and Rxi-XLB columns recommended for their superior selectivity, efficiency, and analysis speed. Dual-column configurations offer flexibility for both mass spectrometric and electron capture detection.

Reference

1. H Choi, J Kim, Y Im, S Lee, Y Kim, The association between some endocrine disruptors and hypospadias in biological samples, J Environ Sci Health Part A Toxic Hazard Subst Environ Eng 47 13 2012 2173–2179
2. N Nassar, P Abeywardana, A Barker, C Bower, Parental occupational exposure to potential endocrine disrupting chemicals and risk of hypospadias in infants, Occup Environ Med 67 9 2010 585–589
3. L Trasande, S Sathyanarayana, AJ Spanier, H Trachtman, TM Attina, EM Urbina, Urinary phthalates are associated with higher blood pressure in childhood, J Pediatr 163 3 2013 747–753
4. EF Werner, JM Braun, K Yolton, JC Khoury, BP Lanphear, The association between maternal urinary phthalate concentrations and blood pressure in pregnancy The HOME Study, Environ Health 14 2015 75
5. JJ Jaakkola, TL Knight, The role of exposure to phthalates from polyvinyl chloride products in the development of asthma and allergies A systematic review and meta-analysis, Environ Health Perspect 116 7 2008 845–853
6. EE Hatch, JW Nelson, RW Stahlhut, TF Webster, Association of endocrine disruptors and obesity Perspectives from epidemiological studies, Int J Androl 33 2 2010 324–332
7. S Net, A Delmont, R Sempere, A Paluselli, B Ouddane, Reliable quantification of phthalates in environmental matrices air water sludge sediment and soil A review, Sci Total Environ 515–516 2015 162–180
8. US Environmental Protection Agency, Method 8061A Phthalate Esters by Gas Chromatography with Electron Capture Detection GC/ECD Rev 1 December 1996
9. D Li, Phthalate determination by dual column set in eight minutes ChromaBLOGraphy Restek Corporation 2015